Right about now, there are writers and analysts already preparing the articles about why the Trump campaign failed. AND right about now, they might be doing the exact same thing in regards to the Biden campaign.
Obviously, as of this writing, we have no idea what’s ACTUALLY going to happen.
But my point is that if you look well enough, with the right perspective, failure is actually pretty easy to analyze. People don’t like to admit it, especially in advance. As JFK once said: Victory has a thousand fathers, but defeat is an orphan.
Why do people, organizations, and businesses fail? Often it’s because they don’t take a clear-eyed look at things, especially when they SHOULD — which is right before things get going.
The reason I raise this right now is that business observers (like me) are talking about the massive surge of new businesses being started right now. Many are doing so because of necessity, which is often the cause of great innovation.
But, sadly, the data tells us that most U.S. businesses fail within the first 4 years. And that’s unfortunately as true for Tri-State businesses as it is for any other.
Why? Often … lack of clear-eyed planning.
Here’s what I mean…
Why a Pre-Mortem Analysis for Any New Tri-State Business is a Necessity
“Not only must we be good, but we must also be good for something.” -Henry David Thoreau
Too many entrepreneurs are blind optimists. (And yes — too many accountants are blind pessimists, I admit.)
Aside from the financials of a new venture, there are obviously other factors that play into its outcome. And my gut is that the people on your Tri-State team already know what they are. They’re probably not writing a book or preparatory articles about it (yet), but they probably have some good ideas.
Over 50% of Cincinnati and other U.S. businesses fail in the first four years. Many that linger past that point are alive in name only. Yet very few entrepreneurs actually believe they have a less than 50% chance of success. They are convinced that those statistics only apply to the other person’s ideas.
The concept of a pre-mortem was designed to help overcome these natural human tendencies to ignore real threats to a business plan. A related concept, the postmortem, or autopsy, was coined by the medical community to determine the cause of death.
Sometimes we wish for hindsight’s clear vision beforehand. If failure is the most likely outcome, the earlier you can recognize it and change course, the better. The pre-mortem looks into the future and attempts to predict what a business venture autopsy will reveal.
In his book The Power of Intuition, Gary Klein offers a five-step exercise to help teams overcome the overconfidence bias. Research has found that people are more clearly able to understand and describe the risks of a venture when they conceive of the failure of their project as certain. If failure is only a contingency, the hopes and aspirations of all involved will neuter any attempts to assess the most dangerous risks.
Before you can begin an effective pre-mortem for your Tri-State business, make sure that everyone on the team is fully familiar with the new venture that will be assessed for failure. This exercise may require an initial presentation and some additional reading so that all participants have a full understanding of the issues involved. Schedule about an hour in a conference room. Each person will need several sheets of paper.
When all arrive, begin by claiming to look into a crystal ball to see the outcome of this new venture. Oh no, the future is cloudy but disastrous. The project is a complete and total failure. Your partners and your clients are upset. No one on the team is talking to one another.
But your crystal ball will not reveal how this happened. The question of the hour is, “What could have caused this?” Ask each team member to suggest 10 reasons for the failure.
In the second step, each member of the team quietly takes three minutes to write down all the reasons they think failure occurred. This decentralized free association will produce many interesting ideas about how this venture may have failed.
All the participants must be given the freedom to share ideas that in other situations would be considered impolite. Too many teams get stuck in a psychological state of groupthink where opposing feelings of loyalty and fear both lead to conformity of ideas. The most pressing challenges are not likely to be shared in an environment that lacks the freedom to speak them.
The third step involves repeatedly going around the room as each person shares one item on their list and a facilitator records these ideas until all have consolidated their lists into one master list.
The fourth step is to prioritize the ideas that grew out of the collective brainstorm. Which two or three appear to the group to be the most threatening? Have each person write these down independently before sharing as a group. Sometimes, the most polished and eager public speakers can be so convincing that others in the group neglect to do their own reasoning.
The final step in your pre-mortem is to reassess the new business venture. Are the opportunities worth the threats involved? Are there ways to strengthen the plan to forestall fiasco?
A pre-mortem has been proven to be effective because it involves a shift in perspective. It’s the difference between asking, “What could go wrong?” and, “What has gone wrong?” The first is a theoretical future perspective, and the second is a historical fact.
An additional, but equally important, benefit from this type of analysis is that it allows team members to be valued for their unique perspectives and observations. Building a shared vision and ownership is vital for developing the most effective teams. Allowing this team to effectively question their own assumptions helps to counter any preconceived ideas.
So, I ask you: Are you willing to send your best ideas to the grave?
And if you want some help in seeing these things clearly, we’re right here: (513) 791-6288
Tri State CPAs
Feel free to forward this article to a Tri-State area (or beyond!) business associate or client you know who could benefit from our assistance. While these particular articles usually relate to business strategy, as you know, we specialize in tax preparation and planning for families and business owners.